
“The things that make me different are the things that make me ME!” – Piglet quote on the wall of our sensory gym
Last week I got an email from one of Howie’s teachers. She explained that they had been working on a math assessment test about money and coins. The directions were to count the money and show your work. The teacher said that Howie had refused to show his work. His explanation was that he didn’t have to “because I have autism.”
She wrote that they had worked through the refusal by reminding him that this was for his third grade teachers and while she knew he could do it in his head, he needed to show his new teachers that he understood the work.
Now Howie has never been a big fan of reviewing concepts. “I already know how to do this!” is a frequent refrain when doing assessments or review work. But this was a new wrinkle. He had never refused to do work because of autism before.
I wrote back and said I was kind of stunned by all of this since we’ve never said anything like that to him or around him before. We’ve always talked about autism – and specifically his autism – in a positive light. Talking about the gifts it brings him. Lately we had been discussing how there are times when different brains have a harder time with some activities, and that’s why sometimes he needed to leave the room to take a test, or use his headphones or have a sensory break. But we’ve never said he couldn’t do…anything.
I expressed my surprise at his statement and said I would talk with him about it.
Later that afternoon, Howie and I were sitting across from each other on the floor of our living room. His iPad was on his lap and he was creating his newest world on his Blocksworld app.
“Hey bud'” I said. ” I heard that you had some trouble working on your math assessment today?”
“Yeah. But the fruit snacks helped me get through it.”
“What was hard?”
“I had to write it all out but I knew the answer.”
“Your teacher said you told her that you couldn’t do the test because you had autism?”
” I said I didn’t have to do the work because I had autism,” he said. He didn’t look up at all.
“Well, autism isn’t an excuse you know,” I said. ” You can do hard things. But you still need to do the work.”
“I didn’t say I couldn’t,” he said. “I said I didn’t have to. I didn’t have to show my work. I could see it and do it in my head.”
I sat there and just looked at him. His eyes never left the iPad, fingers moving and swiping and tapping as he built a cityscape for his Blocksworld cars to drive through.
Not an excuse.
A reason.
Not a negative. A positive.
Not can’t do. Don’t have to to understand.
Part of his gift. He could see it in his head. So why do the extra work?
He wasn’t trying to get out of doing the test itself. Just the showing his work. And not because he didn’t want to.
Because “I didn’t have to.”
He was actually advocating for himself.
“I understand now,” I said. “But you know there will be times when you have to show your work, even when you can do it in your head. It’s important for other people to see what you see.”
“I know,” he said. ” And the fruit snacks were really good.”
***********
In our world, autism isn’t and won’t be an excuse. We’re never going to teach him he can’t do something because of how his brain is wired.
But it can be a reason why things are hard. Or, in this case, easy.
Maybe it’s semantics.
This is why we felt it was important that Howie knows and understands his diagnosis. So he could say, “I see this differently because my brain is wired differently.”
A few weeks ago, M. Kelter of Invisible Strings posted this on his Facebook page:
Without the words to say “because of my autism”, how might this interaction have gone? Alternative scenarios might have involved a long, drawn out stand off, viewed as noncompliance, leaving everyone exhausted, frustrated and miserable.
Leaving my kid feeling like a bad kid. A failure. Different without explanation as to how or why. Removed for long periods of time from his general education classroom as things escalated, keeping him away from his peers.
He knows he leaves to take tests in a quiet space so he doesn’t get distracted. We are working on helping him understand that his aide is there as a “coach” and “interpreter” when he needs help.
But he also needs to know that we will listen to what he is really saying and doing and go beyond the specific words that he is using in order to make sure that we understand their meaning. Because here he was, in his way, appropriately advocating for himself.
It’s our job to make sure we hear him when he does.
“Although you see the world different than me
Sometimes I can touch upon the wonders that you see
All the new colors and pictures you’ve designed
Oh yes, sweet darling
So glad you are a child of mine.
Child of mine, child of mine
Oh yes, sweet darling
So glad you are a child of mine.” – Child of Mine by Carole King
May 27, 2014 at 5:26 pm
Reblogged this on Walkin' on the edge and commented:
A reason, not an excuse. An explanation, not an avoidance. A little piece of understanding of a different perspective and experience.
May 27, 2014 at 6:18 pm
i guess it is about perspective …………how do we look like in other people’s eyes.
May 28, 2014 at 1:28 pm
Fantastic! What an amazing epiphany! This is a great lesson to take into every day,
May 29, 2014 at 12:04 am
If only my teachers had bothered to listen to me when I said I didn’t need to do the work… on everything. There was an incident that still brings me to tears all these years later; I had a writing assignment that took two weeks to do. I got it done that night and turned it in. I was accused of cheating, told to bring in a “rough draft,” and when I said I didn’t need a rough draft, it… got bad. No one listened to me, and I didn’t even tell my parents. Teachers had a lovely habit of speaking for my parents as a way of manipulating me. I know NOW that was abuse, but back then? I was terrified of my parents.
May 29, 2014 at 5:12 pm
I’m so sorry. No child – no one at all – should be made to feel that way, by teachers, parents or anyone. But I am thankful that you are sharing this with me and others. I need to do better at this and be better at helping my kids’ teachers understand this. Please know that I will carry this with me.
May 30, 2014 at 2:29 am
I’m glad that I can help out. I know so many autistic kids whose parents don’t listen to those of us who’ve been there before… Thank you.
May 29, 2014 at 11:58 am
This sounds exactly like my son. He has the same problems in math and he gets very frustrated when he has to show his work.
June 4, 2014 at 9:25 am
As a parent, evolving from awareness to acceptance, I am overwhelmingly grateful to see/read so many more life stories embracing neuro-diversity. It is refreshing & invigorating. Would love to add your blog to my links on mine!
June 4, 2014 at 9:27 am
Oh wow – thank you! Of course!
June 4, 2014 at 10:38 am
Very interesting. This article reminds me of the need to educate teachers on alternative ways of assessing what students know. She could have easily asked him to say out what he was seeing in his head. She could have asked him to act it out or to type it on his iPad. Also, it seems like your son was communicating his awareness that the teacher really didn’t believe that he could do the work abstractly and get to the correct answer and write only the answer concretely on paper. Could it be that she communicated in the request for him to ‘write it down’ that she may think he guessed at the answer? Autism or not, kids need multiple opportunities to communicate how they know what they know.
June 4, 2014 at 10:44 am
Having had conversations with the teachers about this, I think it was mostly about an exercise in following the directions on the sheet (perhaps in prep for the standardized tests he will be taking next year in 3rd grade where you have to show your work to get credit for the answer). I think that’s why she took the route of “let’s do this to show your future teachers that you know it.”
But you are absolutely right. In his IEP he has accommodations for using alternative technology when needed because he just can’t get the answers out of his head onto the paper. There definitely needs to be flexibility – a lot of flexibility – in how we have our kids “show” that they know it. Thank you for this.
June 5, 2014 at 2:16 am
AMAZING post
You have a truly awesome child
June 17, 2014 at 4:20 pm
[…] you see autism not as a limit but as his strength and step out of the diagnosis box to see him as an […]
August 27, 2014 at 4:11 pm
[…] Perhaps it’s semantics again. […]
May 21, 2015 at 4:00 pm
[…] guest post was written by Alysia of Try Defying Gravity and is republished here with […]