So first of all, a big thank you.
I wrote one line last week about my youngest having his second early intervention appointment. One line. And I got the most amazing, most overwhelming support from my friends – both in person and in cyberspace.
I got the phone calls I expected that day, the ones from my mom and from my husband. But what I didn’t expect were the e-mails and comments and tweets (yes, I said tweets…sigh) from my friends here in town and across the globe. I can’t express how much that meant to me. It was so different from when I went through it with Howie and I knew only one person who would understand. To have so many others check in with me…I’m speechless. Thank you.
So, speaking of speechless…
It’s taken me a week to really be able to process our visit with the speech therapist last week. It was the same woman who evaluated Lewis in May, so she was very familiar with our situation. We were able to skip over most of the Michigan Early Intervention Developmental Profile and go right to the speech/language portion. She went through the test, trying to get him to use his words to ask for the puzzle pieces, the blocks, the animals…and got nothing. She tried to get him to repeat her words so he’d start talking. She tested him a bit, forcing him to ask for something before giving it to him. Nothing.
So since he wouldn’t talk, the therapist and I did instead. She asked me how many words I thought he had (about 20). She asked me how many of those words someone else could understand (about 10). And she asked me how many of those words that someone else could understand were also spontaneous.
Spontaneous?
Meaning how many did he say on his own without prompting, without repeating.
About five. Sigh.
The therapist wrote down a bunch of notes and asked Lewis questions. He could follow two or three step directions but wouldn’t say anything to her. I figured I needed to chime in here. He has words, I told her. I said I felt like I was walking a fine line telling her things, but I wanted to be honest. I want him to get help if he needs it, but I was afraid that by telling her the things he could do, it might change his score, leaving him ineligible for services. But I needed to give her the whole picture. It wasn’t fair to Lewis, to the therapist, or to the system if I didn’t.
So I told her everything. I told her he could count to 12, but wasn’t sure if anyone else could understand him. She asked to hear that, and as she listened, she shook her head. “I probably would have known he was saying ‘two’, but only because I knew the context”. I told her he knew all the letters of the alphabet, and tried to sing along with songs but no words came out. I told her that even though I knew he could say “Mama”, he never actually called me that. I told her that I know he understands everything, but he’s starting to get frustrated because he can’t get us to figure out what he wants.
The therapist told me she appreciated my honesty and understood exactly what I was saying. The counting and the letters, while great, isn’t really “speech” in her opinion. It’s just rote sounds back. She’s looking for labels of nouns, verbs to get his wants and needs across, and expressive language. She sat there and scored the speech portion of the Michigan while Lewis had a snack. Then she scored it again. And again.
She looked up at me and her face said it all. Yes, his speech was delayed. But not delayed enough for services.
Same old story for us. Just like our evaluation in May, and just like almost all of Howie’s evaluations, we’re smack dab in the middle of the “gray area”.
I could tell the therapist felt terrible. She told me that she knows he needs help and would really benefit from services. She’s worried about the gap between his expressive and receptive language, and is concerned that he’ll start to get frustrated and we’ll see behavioral problems creep out. She could pick him up under “clinical judgment” for six months, but just like she told me last time, she’s worried that we’d lose time when he really needed it – the 2 1/2 yrs old to 3 years old time frame, where the speech demands are so much higher. She recommended waiting again until January, doing another eval, and then she could pick him up from February to August, right before he starts preschool.
In addition, she gave me some new tips for getting Lewis to start talking. She told me to “sabotage” his day a bit when it was just the two of us home, keeping things from him until he attempts the word. I should concentrate on getting Lewis to say the last sound of the word, because he would use the same “b” sound for “bus” and “ball”. She recommended that I focus on just saying one word, not a two word combination. At that point, I had been trying to get him to say “more juice”, but in her opinion getting him to say just “juice” was the most important part.
(on a side soapbox note, the therapist also told me that if we had qualified, the fees would have been significantly higher than we had paid in the past. Because of budget cuts, the department of public health was forced to either raise fees or increase eligibility requirements even more – by a 50% delay. That meant that two year old would have to be speaking at a one year old level in order to qualify for help, thereby missing a whole group of kiddos who need help. Of course, we all know that it means that when those kids get to school, their delays would have been SO significant that the department of education would have been footing the bill…same pot of money, just different department. Just dumb. ok, off the soapbox)
So, long story even longer…
This past week we’ve been trying really hard to implement her suggestions. I wouldn’t let him down from his high chair until he said “done” instead of “da”. If he wanted a banana, he had to say it and not “na na”. And if he wanted out of his crib, he had to tell me “hi, Mama”.
It’s working. He says “done” – the whole word – when he’s finished eating. He’s saying “ba nana” (with the space). And while he’s still not calling for me with “mama”, he will repeat “hi mama” perfectly when I say it first.
Great, right? So why do I feel so guilty?
In one week of intensive work on my part, we’re getting somewhere. It’s not like he caught up in a week, or will even catch up in a month, but we made progress. Because I was giving him my attention. You know, what a mother should do. A mother who is able to focus on her kid. A mother who isn’t completely exhausted with…everything else. I know it’s pointless to play the “what if” game, but in this case I can’t help it.
Now it’s time for us both to play catch up.
“I may know the word
But not say it
I may love the fruit
But not taste it
I may know the way
To comfort & to soothe
A worried face
But fold my hands
Indifferent” – I May Know The Word by Natalie Merchant
September 23, 2010 at 10:52 pm
First of all, you just reminded me that I forgot to contact you to wish you luck with the evaluation on Friday *sigh* Sorry about that!
Secondly – I can totally understand your frustration with the delay not being enough for services…..I’m not sure how the system works over there but here – we can pay to go to speech privately (but that’s expensive) if they don’t meet the correct criteria?
I’m not sure what option there are in America.
It’s great though to read that he’s attempting some new words….even a little bit of progress is A LOT for our kids
September 23, 2010 at 10:55 pm
Oh, Fiona – don’t be silly! I know you’re always there for me across the world!
We could pay privately for therapy – my husband suggested it that afternoon. We’re mulling it over, and in the meantime trying to get him into a few playgroups to be around kids his own age who won’t talk for him (like what happens with his older brothers!).
I know – any progress is GREAT progress. I just have to remember that!
September 23, 2010 at 10:55 pm
Oh Honey! {{{{hugs}}}}
I know exactly how you feel. But you have to cut yourself some slack. You said you were trying some strategies and the SLP gave you new ones, and the new ones are working. It’s not like you’ve just been staring at the ceiling all day while he runs rampant in the neighborhood!
I’ve got two on the Spectrum and I get the guilt, the what ifs… I just posted something like this yesterday…but you’re doing a great job, and you’re exactly what he needs. And don’t act like being “exhausted with everything else” is invalid. You’re only one person and you’re only human.
{{{hugs}}}
September 23, 2010 at 11:09 pm
funny – I was just reading your post when I saw you commented here!
You’re right – we are only human. It’s hard not to hold yourself to a higher standard, though, especially when you feel like it’s something you could have helped.
Somedays I do feel like staring at the ceiling, but no one will let me!!
thanks for the support as always!
September 23, 2010 at 11:28 pm
I have been having such similar feelings for the past few days. I keep wondering if my older son is having more behaviors because my younger one is so high maintenance and needs so much of my time. Or if my younger guy doesn’t know how to play appropriately or self-soothe because I haven’t had the time to teach him like I am supposed to.
It sucks. I don’t know how to get rid of that guilt and I am guessing it is a common thread among us mommies. But we are only human. We can only do so much.
Keep your head up. You are keeping a close eye on your little guy and getting the help you need to find success. Good job!
September 24, 2010 at 11:49 am
I’d say the guilt is universal for mothers no matter what we do, and is amplified if something is going on with our kids. We just need to plug away and do the best we can I guess!
thanks for the support!
September 23, 2010 at 11:32 pm
Have you gone the private therapy route before? Unfortunately there are loopholes for developmental speech that might allow the insurance company to stick you with the whole bill. That’s something you might look at before deciding to go down that road. I’m really sorry you didn’t qualify…this time. Maybe in six months it’ll be different. Or maybe in six months, with the other two in school, he’ll have made a mountain of progress.
September 24, 2010 at 11:55 am
I’m hoping that when it’s just us at home we can really work on it. I’ll just have to ignore the mess in the house, the laundry…my husband and I did talk about private therapy, but we know it won’t be cheap. I’m looking at a few playgroups first. Thanks for the support that day and everyday!
September 23, 2010 at 11:37 pm
Reading about your little guy reminds me so much of my daughter. She was delayed in speech as well. One of the best things we did was take a course called “More Than Words”. It helped us to help her to start using her words. You can see info about the program here: http://hanen.org.
Don’t be too hard on yourself. (Trust me, I know that is one of those things that is easy to say, hard to do). You’ve got the tools now to help your son, you’re on your way!
September 24, 2010 at 11:56 am
I’m going to check that out! That’s great! Thanks!!
September 24, 2010 at 6:31 am
Oh you know I know exactly how you feel. Just like you probably think I’m too hard on myself, so are you. There is nothing can be done about it- I’ll just have to tell you to stop!
I learned a lot from Pudding’s excellent (private) SLP, so I’ve been using the techniques on Cubby from around 6 months. He has a lot of language, but it is still atypical. Doing the KKI sibling study, we found joint attention problems at 12 months. I focused on these, and they were normal at 15 months. Then there was a problem with his pragmatics at 15 months. And now problem-solving difficulties. It seems like if I concentrate on one thing, another sprouts up behind my back.
It doesn’t mean I don’t keep trying, but give me a day of staring up at the ceiling and I’ll take it! Glad to be one of your “tweeps”
September 24, 2010 at 11:56 am
happy to be one your tweeps too
thanks for the support always! let’s stare at the ceiling together someday.
September 27, 2010 at 6:09 pm
Just wanted to add, I got this book out from the library the other week:
The Late Talker: What to Do If Your Child Isn't Talking Yet
It focuses on dyspraxia, so probably not worth buying unless that is the diagnosis, but one of the chapters had useful hints and strategies, so it is worth checking out of the library if they have it. I’ve heard the Hanen method is excellent too (More Than Words) but expensive and the library doesn’t carry it. I’m always looking for good books about language development.
September 28, 2010 at 1:22 pm
I meant apraxia- blame the lack of sleep!
September 24, 2010 at 11:00 pm
Was told something at my son’s preschool today – that in the early years, they can really only focus on one developmental thing at a time. So when they are learning to walk (gross motor) speech falls off. She forewarned me that if we are focusing on speech, not to expect major advances in other spots. Also to remember that his internal agenda won’t be the same as mine. Not sure if that helps in your case, but it set expectations at a more reasonable level for me since we’re just at the beginning of the speech evaluation/trying to get services track.
September 25, 2010 at 12:59 pm
great advice – I have to remember that. Might be why he’s not sleeping anymore either…
September 24, 2010 at 9:09 am
Be easy with yourself–you changed tactics and have gotten results! Focus on that, and not on the what ifs. I know, easier said than done, but try, please! You’re doing a great job!
September 24, 2010 at 11:57 am
you are right, of course! time to focus on the positives…
September 24, 2010 at 11:25 am
You’re an AMAZING mom. Give yourself credit for that. You listened to the SLP and took her advice and put it into action and you now have results. Congrats on that!
September 24, 2010 at 11:57 am
thank you!
September 24, 2010 at 3:00 pm
We had to encourage Boo with “communication temptations”. We had good luck putting his favourite things in clear containers he couldn’t open himself. Then he had to come get us (or bring the container to us) and say “open” or the name of the toy. Which worked really well until the little bugger figured out the locking mechanisms on the totes, but I took what I could get. Sounds like you’re doing similar things, but there it is if you haven’t quite tried that.
Good luck with all this. I’ll be following along to see how it goes. We got really lucky in that we squeaked into a study on the Early Start Denver Model and scored 4 months of parent coaching for free. Now we’re just reaching the top of the waiting lists for the publically funded therapies.
September 24, 2010 at 3:47 pm
that’s a great suggestion! I’ll have to try it!
September 24, 2010 at 8:01 pm
Oh, friend, I know what you mean. It is so easy to wonder what we might have done wrong or how we may have failed our kids. But you are doing an amazing job! Amazing. You are doing everything possible to help your kids!
I hate to say this, because it bugs me when people say it to me, but don’t be too hard on yourself, ok?
I am soooo glad Lewis is already making progress. Hopefully, this is just a blip and he will catch up, eventually.
September 24, 2010 at 11:03 pm
Someone already said it, but it bears repeating – focus on the early positive results. “we’re getting somewhere.”
And, I know of only good reports on the Hanen method.
September 25, 2010 at 1:00 pm
accentuate the positive! sometimes easier said than done, but always worth repeating.
September 25, 2010 at 1:01 pm
With regard to Sylvia’s comment. Julia’s sleeping pattern is disrupted EVERY time she’s developing a new skill.
It’s a killer.
September 25, 2010 at 2:46 pm
You are a wonderful mother, that is why you are blessed with the wonderful boys that you have.
September 26, 2010 at 6:55 pm
I hate, hate HATE “gray areas”
I also hate, hate HATE Budget cuts, the world over. Why is it always the special needs kids who suffer??? So shortsighted. They’d save money long term by investing in these wonderful children NOW.
Okay.. sorry… I’ll get off my soapbox too (I’ve been on it all day!)
I do hope your Lewis gets the help he needs…keep fighting
xx Jazzy
September 27, 2010 at 10:50 pm
I know this may sound nutty, but perhaps choicing him into another school district and having him re-evaled by them? I did this with my son and we were able to get him what he needed with the new school system where the first one said he did not qualify (which he most certainly DID).
It is very frustrating and I sympathize completely. I send you lots of hugs and virtual Ring Dings.
October 22, 2010 at 10:57 pm
[...] breathing. In recent months, we’ve been in to get his ears cleaned after worrying about his speech delay. Can’t blame the kid for hating the place. He calmed down enough during the appointment [...]
November 22, 2010 at 6:55 pm
[...] all the EI testing we’ve been through, so I quickly filled you in. Long story short, he has speech delays but didn’t qualify for services, but we weren’t really concerned about any other [...]
October 6, 2011 at 1:03 pm
[...] Getting services for him was a delicate dance – the SLP had been in at 18 months. Then 2 years old. Then finally again at 2 1/2 years [...]
December 11, 2012 at 3:01 pm
[...] took me so long to pull the trigger on making the appointments for Lewis. I would make the appointment and then cancel. I would stare at the paperwork. I spent so much time looking for [...]